Monogatari Series Second Season – 09

Monogatari Series Second Season - 09 (7)

So this is probably a good time to start panicking.

After teasing us at the end of the previous episode with talk of the world’s demise, the show gave us the full details in this one. So saving Mayoi’s life may not have created a paradox, but it sure threw a wrench into Koyomi and Shinobu’s lives, with the result that Shinobu turned everyone into vampire zombies. And it also turns out that in this timeline, the seal that Koyomi delivered to the shrine in Nadeko Snake prevented it from gathering energy, so they’re stuck as the lone survivors in this zombie apocalypse. Not an enviable situation.

Monogatari Series Second Season - 09 (1)Monogatari Series Second Season - 09 (3)
Monogatari Series Second Season - 09 (4)Monogatari Series Second Season - 09 (5)

I’m not so sure that 2 months is enough time for all this to have happened. Also, how are they so sure that everything is also like this outside their town?

This series won’t ever be criticized for being too subtle. When it plays with the dangerous consequences of manipulating fate, it jumps right over everything else to demise of the human race. None of this “Oh no, I can’t save my love no matter how many times I try” crap, it’s, “Everyone anyone ever knew or loved is dead.” Shaft could have adapted Koyomi and Shinobu’s conversation as they gradually discovered the situation, but I liked the wordless cold open they put together. Such haunting and beautiful post apocalyptic imagery, accompanied by a shocked silence in a series that’s all about talking, leading right into the opening.

This follows reassurances in prior episodes by Shinobu that time travel doesn’t allow inconvenient things like paradoxes or the changing of fate. Oops. She just keeps messing up in this arc, doesn’t she? To be fair, she was right about paradoxes; the time paradox aspect of Koyomi saving Mayoi’s life causing him not to meet her was not at all a factor in the course of events. Rather, it was a small but vital role that Mayoi played during the events of Tsubasa Cat that lead to humanity’s downfall. One could have predicted such an occurrence by looking at all of Mayoi’s appearances in the series – one might wonder if and when Hitagi confessed to Koyomi if not during Mayoi Snail, for instance. But a zombie apocalypse, there was no way to see that one coming, since we weren’t privy to Shinobu’s secret plan that day.

Monogatari Series Second Season - 09 (8)

This bit was the continuation of a running joke that got cut out regarding Koyomi’s obsession with Shinobu’s collar bones and rib cage. (click image for a gif)

So it turns out that Shinobu was responsible for the apocalypse, and she’s also probably dead by suicide. If you’ve read Kizumonogatari and recall what Kiss-Shot Acerola-Orion Heart-Under-Blade was like, her actions probably didn’t shock you too much. She has never had the most stable of personalities. One of Shinobu’s character traits has been casually dropping mentions of extremely drastic things – time travel in this arc, her comment to Black Hanekawa that she was intending to suck her energy if not for the advice she accidentally gave to her in Tsubasa Tiger, and even this bit about Mr. Donut in Nisemonogatari. But what makes her special is that she isn’t exaggerating in these cases. She really brought Koyomi to the past, and she really destroyed humanity.

I found interesting the revelation in this episode about the connection between Shinobu and Koyomi. While Koyomi has been operating under the assumption that the death of one would mean the death of the other, it actually turns out that the death of one frees the other to return to his or her original state. It makes their already precarious position even more so, since they both have something to gain by killing the other. Makes one think of what Shinobu said in the previous episode about possibly betraying Koyomi. That said, fact remains that Shinobu was aware of this fact the whole time and yet did not once attempt to harm Koyomi. Despite her occasional complaints, it’s evident that she genuinely enjoys her life with him.

Monogatari Series Second Season - 09 (14)

Some creepy zombie-like shuffling in the crowds would have been nice.

The zombie vampires that Shinobu created aren’t quite the same as jiangshi, but they’re close enough, and I guess Nisio didn’t want to telegraph this twist by calling it Mayoi Zombie. I was mixed on Shaft’s depiction of them. On the one hand, they were appropriately surreal and disturbing with their Anti-Spiral look. On the other hand, they were barely animated, with crowds of them doing little more than swaying from side to side most of the time. That’s not very menacing. Other than that little misstep, the production work in this episode was some of the best yet. I already mentioned the beautiful cold open, and the rest of the episode was filled with similarly haunting imagery. Shinobu’s leap to escape the zombies was also treat, a fine display of the series’s over-the-top style. It wasn’t shot the same way, but it had the same sort of controlled chaos feeling of Saki’s explosive flight in the 20th episode of Shinsekai Yori.

Monogatari Series Second Season - 09 (18)

The swooping camera – as if being shot by skydivers – and the constant visual of the sun on the horizon gave this scene a visceral rush. This isn’t even a tenth as big as the biggest leap that Shinobu performs this season, though. (click image for gif)

The biggest visual treat came at the end with the fireworks display. First of all, Shinobu with twin buns in a yukata is ridiculous. Second, that light show was really something else, clearly not something an amateur could put together with over-the-counter products. There was something really poignant about these two, possibly last two people alive on Earth, creating and watching such a wonderful spectacle, using a celebration both to accept their horrible fate and as a way of holding out hope that there may be others. The compression on the official legal stream at Daisuki had no shot at keeping up with the dynamic fine details. Even the TV rips on the torrents had trouble keeping up at times – I can’t wait to see this again on Bluray.

Monogatari Series Second Season - 09 (38)

An amazing shot that the compression couldn’t quite do justice.

As we will quickly discover the next episode, this fireworks scene is special. I had kind of hoped to see the conclusion of the scene to close out the episode, but it will probably make up the cold open of the next episode. As you can safely guess based on the events of Tsubasa Tiger, Koyomi and Shinobu won’t spend eternity surviving in a vampire zombie apocalypse, which means we’re still at least one major twist away from the ending. But already this arc has covered so much in just 3 episodes. I love this un-Monogatari-like lightning quick pacing of this arc, as well as its hectic style of throwing unforeseeable and ridiculous twists in our path. Unlike with Tsubasa Tiger, the production values have consistently been excellent, especially important in this story that focuses more on characters’ actions rather than their words. And with Shaft’s flash forward hints from part 1 still not realized, there’s ample reason to be excited for the next installment of this arc.

Monogatari Series Second Season - 07 C (7)

You can probably guess how soon we’ll be getting to this flash forward.


A math/science geek and a self-dubbed cynical optimist. I don't care if it's deep, if it can make me feel something or laugh, it's fine in my book. @lvlln
Blinklist BlogMarks Delicious Digg Diigo FaceBook Google MySpace Netvibes Newsvine Reddit StumbleUpon Twitter

13 Responses to “Monogatari Series Second Season – 09”

  1. belatkuro says:

    I’ve been asking myself how Araragi and Shinobu are eating in this time, then the next scene they were shopping. Then I ask again, is the food still okay? I mean, it’s already two months(if they really returned in the exact time as before). I doubt there’s any electricity in there so the food must have spoiled a lot now. Ehh, this is what I hate about these paradoxes and apocalypse events. And I forgot to ask last week but how was Araragi able to get his uniform back in the past when they were stalking Mayoi’s house and then go back to wearing casuals when they returned. These minor details really…
    Moving on.

    This is a prime example of the butterfly effect. Just wow. So I wasn’t the only one reminded of the Anti-Spirals with those zombies. I totally forgot about those flash forward scenes in the beginning of this arc. This is less of Mayoi’s arc and more Shinobu’s really but I’m not complaining. This is getting interesting. How many episodes is this arc set for anyway?

    Looking forward to how things will be set to normal. I don’t mind how I already know things will be normal in the end. I’m excited to know how it came to be and that’s what makes this arc pretty interesting.

    • lvlln says:

      If you look at their shopping cart, you can see that most of the food is dry stuff, some cans. I do see a bottle of mayo in there, which definitely has gone bad by this point, unless it was stored in one of Costoo’s large freezers which should be able to maintain a cold enough temperature for 2 months.

      Araragi’s school uniform last episode is explained by Shinobu’s vampire powers. The anime skipped over the details, but Shinobu sucked some of his blood to increase her power, which was what allowed her to “transform” into the middle school Hanekawa version we saw her as. The same power was used to give Koyomi the school uniform so that he wouldn’t stand out.

      The screwy thing here wrt the butterfly effect is that pretty much 99% of everything else stayed the same. 11 years after Mayoi’s life was saved, Heart-Under-Blade still came to Japan, still sucked Koyomi’s blood, and Koyomi still ran into Hitagi, Suruga, Nadeko, Tsubasa. It was just that one detail 2 months ago that caused such a drastic change.

      • Highway says:

        Mass-market mayonnaise doesn’t need to be refrigerated before opening (and it’s arguable that it needs to be refrigerated after opening). It’d be fine for quite a long time.

        The butterfly effect is frequently overstated. And as was mentioned by Shinobu before they saved Mayoi, she probably died the next day or something like that anyway. So the net effect of Mayoi dying one day later is probably nothing… until it comes to her oddity finding Shinobu. It’s actually surprising that there was such a drastic secondary (and not cumulative) effect as a direct result.

  2. skylion says:

    This bit was the continuation of a running joke that got cut out regarding Koyomi’s obsession with Shinobu’s collar bones and rib cage

    …and a running trend on tumblr. And on my gravatar….

  3. BlackBriar says:

    How many people does it take to throw the world into annihilation? Just one misguided teenager. This result is one of the possible outcomes when you’re messing with the timeline.

    Well, I’d love the idea of an anime world dominated by vampires but I have to say this version sucks big time. And the victims looked like soulless charred black husks rather than vampires or former vampires, to be more specific (There go my hopes of seeing a hot vampire Karen and Senjougahara walking about). Koyomi wearing a face of ignorance to his current situation is admirable but at the same time pathetic. There’s no way anyone would be content living like that.

    I’m not so sure that 2 months is enough time for all this to have happened. Also, how are they so sure that everything is also like this outside their town?

    One thing that should never be done in these kinds of shows is underestimate the supernatural. For the possibilities, I’m sure before everything went critical, those who were turned with their converted instincts were fighting for power amongst themselves and you that as a species, they have devastating physical and mental prowess. Remember that vampire society is a strict pyramid structure. The strongest always stands above the others. And the more the number increases, the more widespread the damage would be.

    • lvlln says:

      Ha, the thought of seeing vampire versions of the girls never even crossed my mind. Perhaps if we had jumped to a date closer to that fateful 6/14, we might have been able to see some. Then again, it looks like everything went down very quickly, looking at how abruptly the newspapers stopped. Depending on the chaos at the time, the vampires certainly could have done major damage to the buildings and other structures, but I don’t see the ivy growing over the buildings within just 2 months.

  4. skylion says:

    This thought just grabbed me by the shirt lapels…

    In fifteen episodes of Bake, 11 of Nise, the Neko Kuro episodes, five episodes of Neko Shiro, and two episodes of Mayo Jiangshi..this is the first time we have seen anyone but the main cast, and other supporting characters. In other words, we now get to see the larger population of the so called Empty World of the story…and look what they are…

    • lvlln says:

      We did see some extras in the first 2 parts of Mayoi Jiangshi, in the form of the middle school girls and the policewoman. Of course, depending on one’s interpretation, the policewoman might be Koyomi’s mother, though I haven’t seen convincing evidence for that. But even in Neko White, scenes involving extras were edited down, for instance when Tsubasa first saw her house on fire, she was watching with her entire class at the time, not just with Hitagi.

  5. Foshizzel says:

    Shinobu’s reactions are the best <3

    I love this arc so far!

  6. edo says:

    Shinobu’s reaction when koyomi touched her frome behind was odd… isn’t she used to that ?

    • BlackBriar says:

      Shinobu was so lost in thought and guilt that it shook her to the core and affected her character for a moment. That’s why she got surprised when Koyomi touched her.

Leave a Reply