Who will WIN this BATTLE?! – Index Vs Haruna

Can it get more lolier than this? – Index Vs Haruna

Ever had a discussion about which anime character would win in a fight?! Well, this post springs from that idea and a few other ideas mashed together. So, these can be anime characters from any series, movies or OVAs. Each character has all of their abilities, skills and powers to make them sort of fair even if they come from any heavy arc type of show. I will also throw in a tiny back story, to explain why these two characters are fighting in the first place.

Today’s match!

Index Versus Haruna!

Random story: Index saw a sign in a local ramen shop giving away free samples of a tasty new flavour. Just as she was about to grab the last bowl of ramen, another hand reaches out to grab the bowl. Index turns to find a strange girl, wearing a pink outfit glaring back at her. They begin to argue over who should get this last bowl of ramen and that is when all hell breaks loose.

So who do you think would actually win?

Who will WIN this BATTLE?! - Index Vs Haruna

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Credits: Index art by Suruume and Haruna art by Yumesato Makura.

Main image Credits: Index by Nyoronyoro and Haruna art by Ibuki mana


Is huge anime fan from Florida! who loves to watch anime and also enjoys drawing and collecting pictures, my favorite genre of anime has to be Mecha, there is just something awesome about giant robots beating the crap out of each other! Other than that type of show, I love a good comedy or action series :D
Blinklist BlogMarks Delicious Digg Diigo FaceBook Google MySpace Netvibes Newsvine Reddit StumbleUpon Twitter

73 Responses to “Who will WIN this BATTLE?! – Index Vs Haruna”

  1. Moni Chan says:

    Oh snap don’t tell me I have to decide. Or should I vote for both

    • Foshizzel says:

      Hahahaha true xD Would be hard to vote for these two if you love both Zombie and Index, then again Index is old and busted Haruna is the new hotness xD

  2. Kyokai says:

    I’ll vote for Haruna, as I like her more. xD

  3. Foshizzel says:

    Haruna channn!!! <3 but I think Index would win a eating contest hands down 😛

  4. Elyon says:

    Haruna-chan ftw!! 😀

  5. Namika says:

    Looks like Haruna-chan is going to win.. :3

  6. Ruby says:

    This seems like a more creative idea of Sea Slug’s polls xD
    I think Haruna is gonna win, she can power up and stuff + she has a zombie and a powerful professor looking after her~ I haven’t seen much of index to judge tho.

    • Foshizzel says:

      Somewhat but a bit different 😛

      True! Haruna does have more cool power ups than poor old Index, I was reading if Index actually used more of her own magic she would be the most “powerful” in the series.

      But I like Haruna too she has lots of fire in her xD

  7. Overcooled says:

    I probably shouldn’t vote since I only know Haruna. XD

    IF YOU DO THIS AGAIN MAKE SURE YOU KEEP DOING THE “RANDOM STORY.” I really like that part, adds more flavour than just “lol, which is better?”

    • Foshizzel says:

      Wooooo more Haruna love!!

      Hahah yes sounds like a plan, I figured a fight between these two would easily be started with food! Yes agreed it does make it more fun than just “pick one”

  8. Hato-kun says:

    But… They are both annoying….

    • Foshizzel says:

      I guess next time there should be a take out both at once option? xD

      Well go for who looks better lmao!

    • amado says:

      only index is annoying and useless.
      haruna not so much…

      • Foshizzel says:

        Hahah truth, Index gets in the way and eats food! shocked Accelerator put up with her xD

  9. BlackBriar says:

    Dude, this is a decision that definitly pulls you by the hair but I’m gonna have to go with Haruna. She’s a bottomless pit of girl who gives Index a run for money. She’ll eat a boatload of food and still has frightningly enough room for seconds, thirds and maybe even fourths. And we haven’t even gotten to the desert part yet. She’s Index’s rival for life when it comes to food unless there is another girl with the same traits who comes along the way.

    • Foshizzel says:

      True that, Haruna actually does fight when the time comes down to it. Hahah yes rivals who can eat a whole buffet all to themselves! Someone needs to draw that happening…

      • BlackBriar says:

        That’s a scary thought. She scarfs everything down, works it all off by fighting alongside her friends and in doing so, empties that disposal she calls a stomach so she can go at again. That’s a vicious cycle. Where does Ayumu get the money to keep up with Haruna. There’s no stopping this gluttonous Masou Shoujou and it’s the situation between Touma and that equally gluttonous nun Index. I’d be afraid to be in anyone of those guys shoes.

        • Foshizzel says:

          True hahah I don’t know how Aikawa or Touma pay to feed those two, probably steals money? Or both come from rich families hahaha

        • amado says:

          haruna is not a glutton. I cant see where you got that. she likes to eat sweets but yuu also likes sweets too.

    • amado says:

      hey, haruna isnt like that.

      in fact, she helps in cooking the food around and not being a total freeloader. I would like to taste those scrambled eggs….

      • Foshizzel says:

        Ohhh right the glowing eggs hahaha almost forgot about that, she can cook I was going to list pros and cons but was like Acck to much thought.

  10. Reaper says:

    Index would win; not only would she eat you out of your wallet, but she could also blast you all the way to Mars whenever she’s like that protective state (anyone remember season one? She’s firing her PEW PEW LAZORS!) Haruna…I don’t know, I like her character but it’s too blatant and upfront…which isn’t always a bad thing but at least with Index, it’s controlled and not so…Studio Deen-style. Yeah, that’s another point. JC Staff>Studio Deen. Enough said.

    • Foshizzel says:

      Hahaha yeah I remember those episodes in season one of index, when she goes out of control those were always good. Sadly she can’t use much of her own magic! Which sucks that would make Index a good series.

      Haruna is well confident and pushy, not bad character traits for her anyway. True based on studio’s alone JC Staff always has fun character designs.

      Well it comes down to your personal favorites either studio,character personality or series itself.

  11. sassy says:

    Easy answer is easy.

  12. Ness says:

    There should be a third option. XD

  13. BlackLagoon187 says:

    Tensai Mahou Shoujo wins but throw in a different character from Index *ahem*Misaka*ahem* then it’s a different story 😀

    • Foshizzel says:

      Yes! I am saving Misaka for another fight down the road, don’t want to have to much Index going on! So gotta think of a good match for her of course.

      • BlackBriar says:

        I suggest Seraphim as a perfect match for Misaka. They’re both powerful and headstrong. It’s a perfect fight: Electric esper against a leaf vampire ninja.

        • BlackBriar says:

          We can put Seraphim against Misaka and Yuki against Kuroko for good measure. A tag-team match between espers and vampires. That would sound awesome.

  14. amado says:

    go haruna, she accepted that she cant be the loved one and she brightens the mood and makes it more fun.

    index is a brat and whiney. she makes it more annoying.

    haruna will win through the “mistiltein kick”. index wont see it coming.

    • Foshizzel says:

      yep agreed with you there she does make people smile 😀

      Hahahah yes taht mistiltein kick! it’s the best magical girl attack ever!

  15. AlexBERKUT says:

    Oh. Don’t underestimate Index. Haruna may have her kawaish pink chainsaw, and Index may be weak most of time, But Index have a Touma, which all_vanishing magic hand is good for breaking wonder saws, killing zombies and tearing apart mahou shoujo dress suit…

    • Foshizzel says:

      Oh I wont underestimate Index’s power! After all I did read she has the most powerful magic. I wish JC Staff would explore that more openly and let her do something with all her magic!

      Yeah she could complain and Touma would do something xD

  16. MikADo says:

    you guys are all wrong!
    we can breathe right now thanks to air
    so it is natural that we have to pick
    the air, not Haruna!

  17. Dan-go says:

    haruna will just go all naked and fan servicey (very awesome but not the best tactics in a fight)….atleast index can actually DO things

    • amado says:

      she can pull off the most unexpected and ultimate attack:
      “Mystiltein Kick”
      no one will see it coming….

    • Foshizzel says:

      Index bites, Haruna kicks your ass xD

      • AlexBERKUT says:

        Most terrifying bite, if you ask. Index wait until her victim lose attention, then she rush from behind… and BITE. She clings and torment her victim until it bleeds. She move each tooth separately, and use them like a saw, to cut bones, and get to brains.

        p.s. sorry for bad English if it’s bad.
        p.p.s. Go Go Index!

  18. None of them will win because they will both be exiled for tainted souls.

    Index = Gluttony
    Haruna = murder

    Kyuubey’s shall triumph ~

  19. amado says:

    if you think about it, its actually quite a good match up:

    haruna temporarily lost her magic cause of ayumu.
    index doesnt know she can use magic.

    but haruna is athletic and has a chain saw. and I dont think she needs to become a masou shoujo to use the “Mistyltein kick”.

    • Foshizzel says:

      Yep I had some help picking this match up, If you read Haruna’s bio compared to Index they are similar. Both girls have clothing that protects them from damage, and can both use magic.

      Right Haruna is more athletic compared to Index unless its food then she can run xD but in the end the chainsaw wins, and of course that “KICK” 😛

    • MikADo says:

      at least Index can disrupt or intercept the control of other magician’s spells 😛

      • amado says:

        haruna will then just fight with her chainsaw and close combat.

        remember, she easily knocked ayumu out of her room when he “peaked”.

  20. Foshizzel says:

    Seems this is very popular! I shall have to get on the ball and make some more of these battles 😀 Awesome responses!

    • AlexBERKUT says:

      Hooray! More girls, more fun. Survival championship sounds like good idea 🙂

    • MikADo says:

      they do stuff like these online anyways 😛
      they have tournaments with thousands of votes
      to decide the best character of the year XD
      the 2ch tournament winner for 2010 was Azusa btw

Leave a Reply